Hello Commonsparrow3,commonsparrow3 wrote: ↑December 17th, 2019, 4:03 pm Okay, since I neglected to mention it, I guess we have two versions of the same carol this year! (I make myself a mental note to include something about this in next year's instructions!)
As to your recording -- it's completely lovely, and I'd hate to do without it! That's reason enough to include it! It is PL OK! Thank you, Adrian!
Tricia, just for information -- the file name for the first version was ccc19_bleakmidwinter_rl and the file name for the second version was ccc19_inthebleakmidwinter_aps So there's no chance of the files overwriting each other by accident. Sorting the files in the MW alphabetically means one will end up in the b's and the other in the i's, so they won't be immediately one after the other. So listeners won't hear the same carol immediately repeated, but only after other carols in between. (Again, I make that mental note for next year!)
I did wonder about the duplicate, I found this in the instructions "But remember, it doesn't matter if the carol has been recorded before." and took this to mean it was OK. I see now that this statement related to "before in librivox" rather than "before in this collection". So, I think I made a mistake here. I'm happy for my recording not to be included if it creates any kind of issue.
Best Regards and Merry Christmas,
Adrian