[Complete]Logic by John Stuart Mill - loa

[kristakz]

section 62, 64, 68, 69 and 70 PL Notes

Section 62

PL OK

Section 64 - begins with a click and about 2 seconds of silence

PL OK

Section 68
My original notes on my system had the Greek text marked in Section 68, so I believe that this error is caused by a slip of my fingers when I edited the magic window.
Regardless, I extracted the two sections of text from the html, and re-ran my Greek analysis macros. The small (sections 68 and 69) document can be downloaded from www.ChrisGreaves.com/Downloads/Sections 68-69.doc in which SIX isolated Greek words are identified. My timing marks correspond to yours.

Code: Select all

Section 68 Book IV Chapter V On The Natural History Of The Variations In The Meaning Of Terms
25:31	(1) Αρσενίκον
27:17	(2) ὀπὸς
27:38	(3) ἐλαύνω
30:17	(4) Θεός
31:17	(5) ποίητης
31:36	(6) φυσίκος

Remains marked as your "See PL notes" until we confirm my analysis. I am aware that we will need to revisit this section once the Greek text is recorded.

I am really uncomfortable with the idea of marking something "PL OK" which still needs edits - whether Greek or otherwise. Can we please leave this as "see PL notes" until the Greek is ready?

Section 69
My repeated analysis reveals no Greek text in this section.
Marked (I removed the "needs Greek" comment)

Thanks. I'll PL this in the next set.

Section 70

PL OK

[ChrisGreaves]

I am really uncomfortable with the idea of marking something "PL OK" which still needs edits - whether Greek or otherwise. Can we please leave this as "see PL notes" until the Greek is ready?

My mistake, and I do remember this conversation from back around page 2 or 3 or thereabouts.
I see that you have marked it PLNotes, so I do believe that you have beaten me to the correction.
I absolutely agree with you.
Cheers, Chris

[kristakz]

Section 69 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Sections 71 & 72 are PL OK

[ChrisGreaves]

Sections 71 & 72 are PL OK

Thank you, Krista
Cheers, Chris

[kristakz]

Section 73 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Section 77 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Section 82 is PL OK
And now that I've cherry picked a few short sections, I'll go back and pick up the ones I skipped

[kristakz]

Section 75 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Section 79 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Section 76:

34:10 - I hear "and generally so important a portion ", text says "and generally so unimportant a portion "


Such a tiny little change. You're really making me pay attention

[kristakz]

Section 83:
4:52 - I hear "But with the doctrine of causation", text says "But the doctrine of causation"

Section 84 is PL OK

[kristakz]

Section 87:

00:10 - I hear "book 6, chapter 5", but this is "Book 6, Chapter 6"

[kristakz]

Section 85:

11:33 - I hear "two impressions have frequently experienced ", text says "two impressions have been frequently experienced "
24:36 - I hear "opinion of all psychologists", text says "opinion of all physiologists"

[ChrisGreaves]

Section 85:
11:33 - I hear "two impressions have frequently experienced ", text says "two impressions have been frequently experienced "
24:36 - I hear "opinion of all psychologists", text says "opinion of all physiologists"

Section 76: 34:10 - I hear "and generally so important a portion ", text says "and generally so unimportant a portion " Such a tiny little change. You're really making me pay attention
Replaced 34:04-34:27 with corrected text. "What is actually on any occasion perceived by our senses being so minute in amount, and generally so unimportant a portion of the state of facts which we wish to ascertain or to communicate; it would be absurd to say that either in our observations, or in conveying their result to others, we ought not to mingle inference with fact;"
Length 41:02
GapsGT2 ok
Export/Checker ok

Section 83: 4:52 - I hear "But with the doctrine of causation", text says "But the doctrine of causation"
Replaced 04:51-05:04 with corrected text "But the doctrine of causation, when considered as obtaining between our volitions and their antecedents, is almost universally conceived as involving more than this."
Length 23:42
GapsGT2 ok
Export/Checker ok

Section 87: 00:10 - I hear "book 6, chapter 5", but this is "Book 6, Chapter 6"
Replaced 00:00-00:15 with a corrected Introduction "Section Eighty Seven of A System of Logic, by John Stuart Mill. This LibriVox recording is in the public domain. Book six, chapter six, General Considerations On The Social Science"
Length 23:42
GapsGT2 ok
Export/Checker ok

Section 85:11:33 - I hear "two impressions have frequently experienced ", text says "two impressions have been frequently experienced "
Replaced 11:29 -11:49 with corrected text "The second is, that when two impressions have been frequently experienced (or even thought of) either simultaneously or in immediate succession, then whenever one of these impressions, or the idea of it, recurs, it tends to excite the idea of the other."
24:36 - I hear "opinion of all psychologists", text says "opinion of all physiologists"
Replaced 24:18-24:40 with corrected text "That the previous mental history of the individuals must have some share in producing or in modifying the whole of their mental character, is an inevitable consequence of the laws of mind; but that differences of bodily structure also co-operate, is the opinion of all physiologists, confirmed by common experience."
Length 33:52
GapsGT2 ok
Export/Checker ok

https://librivox.org/uploads/lorda/logicjohnstuartmill_76_mill_128kb.mp3
https://librivox.org/uploads/lorda/logicjohnstuartmill_83_mill_128kb.mp3
https://librivox.org/uploads/lorda/logicjohnstuartmill_87_mill_128kb.mp3
https://librivox.org/uploads/lorda/logicjohnstuartmill_85_mill_128kb.mp3

Cheers, Chris